29. |
otu ā€domesticated
bovineā€™ |
29
a. |
ata tu ā€our
domesticated bovineā€™ |
29
b. |
ata pen ā€our
penā€™ |
29
c. |
ata cĆ¼khu
ā€our cĆ¼khuā€™ |
|
tu is never instanced as a unit
in its own right but in a linguistic context such as the
one adduced above, tu may be deemed a word because
the linguistic elements viz., pen ā€penā€™ and cĆ¼khu
ā€plot of land in the village which is earmarked for
individualsā€™ with which it may be said to be in a relation
of substitution are words. |
Substitutability as a presystematic diagnostic tool is sufficient
in some cases and not sufficient in certain others. Postverbal
adverbs illustrate the former and case markers the latter.
mazhĆ¼ ā€wellā€™ is an adverb derived from the verb
zhĆ¼ ā€to be goodā€™. Since zhĆ¼ ā€to be goodā€™
is a word, its derivative mazhĆ¼ , the
adverb is a word too. |
30 |
aiho1 |
odzĆ¼ |
da2 |
mazhĆ¼3
-we2 |
|
Daiho1 |
swims2 |
well3
|
|
|
Other postverbal adverbs, absolute, or derived like mazhĆ¼
ā€wellā€™, form a substitution class along with mazhĆ¼. Since
mazhĆ¼ has been ruled a word, other postverbial adverbs are
words, too, despite the fact that they are absolute forms
: |
30.
a. |
aiho1 |
odzĆ¼ da2 |
zhazha3
-we4 |
|
Daiho1 |
often3 |
swims2
|
|
mazhĆ¼ ā€wellā€™ and zhazha ā€often ; frequentlyā€™
are in a relation of substitution; since mazhĆ¼
is a word on other criteria, zhazha is one too.
In the case of case markers, on the other hand, Substitutability
is not sufficient. Case markers are clearly in a relation
of substitution, but they could be either words or affixes
: |
31
a. |
ai1 |
kar-yi2 |
nie3 |
|
|
I1
saw3 |
[the] doctor2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
31
b. |
ai1 |
kar2 |
he3 |
tae4
|
|
I1
went4 |
[lit, near]3 |
[the] doctor2
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
31
c. |
ai1 |
kar
2 |
kotu3 |
tae4
|
|
I1
went4 |
upto3 |
[the] doctor2
|
|
|
In the three sentences above, the forms that immediately
follow the noun kar
ā€doctorā€™ are clearly in a relation of substitution as
they have identical linguistic function viz., that of
marking the relation between kar
ā€doctorā€™ the noun and ta ā€to goā€™ the verb. But by the
criterion of potential pause, -yi is a nonword
[a suffix], kotu ā€uptoā€™ a word, a postposition and he
ā€nearā€™ more a word, a postposition than a nonword [a suffix].
Substitutability is not sufficient on another score viz.
that it not only can not tell words from affixes as [e.g.a.
31 a-c] show, but also cannot tell words from phrase,
since phrases are substitutable for words.
|
32a. |
pfo-no1 |
a2 |
na-pĆ¼i3 |
ko-e |
|
|
|
|
she1 |
[is] my 2 |
daughter3
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
32b. |
idu1
|
vu-ko-o2 |
mamĆ¼i |
ka-zhĆ¼-pĆ¼i3
|
a4
|
na-pĆ¼i5 |
ko-e |
|
theprettyone3 |
whocame2 |
yesterday1 |
[is]
|
my4 |
daughter |
|
|
pfo-no of 32a and idu vu-ko-o mamĆ¼i kazhĆ¼-pĆ¼i
of 32b are in a relation of substitution but the former
is a word and the latter a phrase. Substitutability is,
however, necessary. |
The criteria are dissonant rather than consonant giving
rise to the need to hiearchise them so as to arrive at
the discrete Mao word. Isolability, for instance, conflicts
with Potential Mobility, Potential Pause and Elliptibility;
an isolable unit need not be potentially mobile or elliptible
or be marked by potential pause. But the resort to the
expedient of hiearchisation is of no avail because while
Insolubility/potential pause override all the other criteria
whenever the two conflict with the latter, there are cases
where Isolability overrides Potential pause and cases
where Potential Pause overrides Isolability: le,
the future tense auxiliary is isolable but there is no
pause marking its boundary with the preceding linguistic
element, but it is a word ; postpositions have potential
pause marking their boundary with the nouns that precede
them, but postpositions are not isolable, but are words.
The result : there seems to be no discrete Mao word, available
for a rigorous global definition, although in particular
instances it is possible to identify the word in the majority
of cases. For instance, Potential Pause is decisive except
when it is overridden by Isolability.
|